Thomas Gaultier
Menu

Physical and Economic Displacement: Why the Distinction Decides the Outcome

Thomas Gaultier 10 min read

Most resettlement programmes fail on the loss that never involved a removal van. A house that has to be moved gets a plan, a budget, an architect and a lender’s attention. A field that gets fenced off, a grazing route that is cut, a stretch of river that can no longer be reached: each gets a line in a compensation schedule. Both are displacement under the international standard. Only one of them is treated as displacement on most sites.

That gap is where a large share of land conflict comes from. I was brought in as an independent mediator to work through a backlog of more than 2,000 community claims against a mining operation in Mozambique. A striking number of the claimants had never moved house. They had lost access to something they used to live on. The company’s files treated them as compensation cases. The families treated themselves as displaced. The distinction sounds technical. In practice it decided who got a livelihood plan and who got a cheque, and therefore who was still angry three years later.

This article is about that distinction, why economic displacement is systematically undercounted, and what a plan that fits the loss looks like.

Two categories, one obligation

IFC Performance Standard 5 draws the line cleanly. Physical displacement is relocation or loss of shelter. Economic displacement is loss of assets, or loss of access to assets, that leads to loss of income sources or other means of livelihood. The same land acquisition can do both at once, and paragraph 18 says so in plain words: the requirements for physical and economic displacement may apply simultaneously.

What matters for practice is that the standard attaches a planning obligation to each category. Physical displacement requires a Resettlement Action Plan, whatever the number of households. Economic displacement on its own requires a Livelihood Restoration Plan. Where a project causes both, the livelihood requirements are folded into the resettlement plan rather than dropped. Paragraph 26 closes the door on the most common evasion: the livelihood provisions apply regardless of whether or not the affected people are physically displaced.

The definition of livelihood is deliberately wide. The footnote to the standard lists wage income, agriculture, fishing, foraging, other natural-resource-based livelihoods, petty trade and bartering. A woman who sells charcoal from a woodlot the haul road now crosses has a livelihood under this definition. So does a family whose cattle used a corridor that a fence has closed. Neither appears in a structure survey.

So the legal grammar is not a lawyer’s detail. It decides which households get a plan with a restoration test attached, and which get a one-time payment and a closed file. Getting the category right at the census is the single cheapest thing a project can do to avoid a decade of grievances.

Why economic displacement gets undercounted

The census is built around things that can be photographed and measured. Structures, trees, standing crops, wells. A surveyor with a tablet and a GPS can record a house in an afternoon. Recording who uses a stretch of floodplain in which season, and what they take from it, needs a different method and more time. Most projects do not budget for that method, so the census sees the house and misses the field.

Michael Cernea’s Impoverishment Risks and Reconstruction model has been warning about this since 1997. Of his eight risks, two are almost entirely about economic displacement: loss of access to common property resources, and joblessness. A third, food insecurity, follows directly from them. Common property is the classic blind spot. Nobody owns the riverbank, the forest patch or the communal pasture, so nobody is listed as its owner, so its loss is compensated to nobody. The families who depended on it discover the loss when the fence goes up.

The eligibility categories in the standard make this worse if they are applied lazily. Paragraph 17 recognises three groups. People with formal legal rights. People with a claim that is recognised or recognisable under national law, including customary tenure. And people with no recognisable claim at all. The third group is still entitled to compensation for lost assets other than land and to livelihood assistance. On many sites the third group is quietly treated as ineligible, because the surveyor was told to record owners. Users are not owners. Users are the people who get economically displaced.

Then there is the cut-off date. The standard allows a project to set one and to refuse claims from people who arrive afterwards. That is a reasonable protection against opportunistic settlement. It becomes a weapon when the cut-off is declared before seasonal users have been identified, so that a herder who returns in the dry season is recorded as an encroacher. Paragraph 23 protects the project only where the date was clearly established and made public. A date the affected people first heard about at the mediation table does not meet that test. In my experience it is one of the fastest ways to turn a compensation claim into a dispute about legitimacy.

What the household actually loses

Sit with an economically displaced family and ask what changed. The answers are rarely about the asset that was valued. They are about time, distance and fallback.

Time, because the replacement field is an hour further away, so the working day shortens and the children walk. Distance, because water that was a ten-minute carry is now a forty-minute carry, and that cost falls on women. Fallback, because the wild foods, fish or firewood that carried the household through a bad harvest are gone. No schedule has a line for the insurance value of a forest. A valuation captures the standing crop. It does not capture the fact that the household’s risk profile has changed for a generation.

This is why the standard insists that compensation for assets and restoration of livelihood are two separate obligations. Paragraph 27 covers the asset: full replacement cost, which the standard defines as market value plus transaction costs with no deduction for depreciation. Paragraph 28 covers the livelihood, and it is explicit about the order of preference. For land-based livelihoods, replacement land of at least equivalent productive potential and location is to be offered as a matter of priority. For natural-resource-based livelihoods, the first option is continued access to the resource, then access to an equivalent alternative. Benefits should be collective rather than individual where that fits how the resource was used. Only when those are not possible do credit, training, cash or employment come in. The standard then adds a sentence I quote to every client: cash compensation alone is frequently insufficient to restore livelihoods.

Paragraph 29 adds transitional support for as long as it reasonably takes to restore income-earning capacity. Not a fixed number of months. As long as it takes. A project that pays three months of transitional allowance for a livelihood that takes three growing seasons to re-establish has met a budget line and failed the standard.

The plan that fits the loss

A Livelihood Restoration Plan worth the name is built from the loss outward, not from the budget inward. It starts by naming every category of economic displacement the census found, including the ones without an owner. It states an entitlement for each category, provided, in the standard’s words, in a transparent, consistent and equitable manner. It sets a restoration target that can be measured against the baseline: production levels, income, standards of living. And it says when the plan is complete. Under paragraph 25 that is when people have received their entitlements and have had adequate opportunity to re-establish their livelihoods, not when the last payment cleared.

Three design choices separate the plans that work from the ones that generate claims. First, land before cash, wherever land-based livelihoods are involved, and land that people have walked and accepted rather than land that appears on a map. Second, entitlements for users as well as owners, with collective arrangements for common property so that the woodlot or fishing ground is replaced for the group that used it. Third, a monitoring rhythm that continues until the restoration target is met, with the affected people consulted during monitoring, as paragraph 14 requires. A plan without a restoration test is a compensation schedule with a longer name.

The Social Impact Assessment is where these categories should first appear. A community baseline that records land use by season and by user is the only defensible basis for the restoration target. If the baseline recorded structures and nothing else, the plan cannot be better than the baseline.

Where the disputes come from, and why they land in mediation

The disputes I see from economic displacement fall into a small number of shapes. A household says it lost access to a resource and the company says the household was never on the list. A user says the cut-off date was never announced in their village. A group says the pasture was collective and the company paid one man for it. A family accepted a cash payment for a field, spent it on a funeral and school fees within a season, and now has neither field nor money. In each case the argument is not really about the sum. It is about whether the loss counted as displacement at all.

That is exactly the kind of dispute that a grievance procedure built around payment amounts cannot resolve, and that litigation resolves slowly and badly. A court asks whether the household had a legal right to the land. The standard asks a different question: whether the household lost its means of living. The answer to the second question is often yes when the answer to the first is no. Structured dialogue with an independent third party is where the two questions can be held apart. Evidence about actual use can be heard, and an entitlement agreed that fits the loss. The land and resettlement disputes I describe in Land Access and Resettlement Disputes almost always contain an unrecognised economic displacement at their core.

Test whether your census sees the field as well as the house

Before a census closes, run it against the Economic Displacement Screening Checklist. It is a 16-point checklist in five sections. They cover users beyond owners, seasonal and common-property use, fair eligibility rules and cut-off dates, entitlements that fit the loss, and a restoration target with a monitoring rhythm. Score each item In place, Partial or Absent. A column of Absents in the first two sections tells you the plan is about to compensate structures and miss livelihoods. That is the pattern behind most of the claims that reach me years later. Use it early, when the finding is cheap to act on. Download the Economic Displacement Screening Checklist

Recognise the loss first, then negotiate the remedy

Companies do not undercount economic displacement out of malice. They undercount it because the methods that find it are slower than the methods that find houses. A schedule of payments also feels finished in a way a livelihood plan never quite does. The cost of that shortcut arrives later, as a grievance backlog, a blockade at the haul road, or a lender’s audit that reopens files everyone thought were closed. Livelihoods and investments are lost together when a displaced family is treated as a payee.

The way through is to treat the recognition of loss as the first negotiation, before any figure is discussed. That negotiation belongs in a structured process both sides trust. This is the discipline the Social Accord Architecture builds in from its first phase. Diagnostic Mapping records who uses what land, when and for what, before the agreement is designed, so that economic displacement is a known input rather than a later surprise. Where a dispute has already formed, a mediated process lets the company and the affected households establish what was lost on the evidence of use. They can then agree an entitlement that restores it and write a restoration test both can check. Dual accountability is what makes that agreement hold. The company is accountable for delivering the land, the access or the transitional support. The community is accountable for using the process rather than the road.

One practical step for your next land take. Before the cut-off date is set, walk the boundary with the people who use the land, in the season they use it, and write down what you see. That walk costs a few days. Not taking it costs years. To design a livelihood restoration process or mediate a displacement dispute, reach me at thomas@thomasgaultier.com.

I am Thomas Gaultier. I mediate company-community disputes in mining, oil and gas, and energy projects, and I have resolved more than 2,000 claims across Sub-Saharan Africa and Europe. More about the work, or tell me what you are dealing with.

If the relationship around a project is under pressure, or heading there, let us talk.

A 30-minute call is enough for me to understand the situation and tell you honestly whether I can help. Active opposition, a social license problem, an FPIC process that needs an independent facilitator, a negotiation a community has to prepare for, or a conflict that is not public yet but will be. It makes no difference which side of the table you are on. No obligation, no generalist pitch.

Every first conversation is confidential.

Cover of Legacy Grievances and Historical Claims by Thomas Gaultier

New release, and the last one

Legacy Grievances and Historical Claims

The tenth and final volume completes the library. It is the field guide to harm that outlived the operation: transitional justice adapted to corporate disputes, successor liability when the asset changes hands, and the pathway behind more than two thousand resolved claims.