Thomas Gaultier
Menu

Compensation at Replacement Cost: Where Valuation Disputes Start

Thomas Gaultier 9 min read

Most compensation disputes are not about greed. They are about method. A family is offered a figure for a mango tree, a house or a hectare of cassava. The figure came from a schedule they have never seen, produced by a method nobody explained, at a rate set by a ministry in a year they cannot remember. They compare it with what it would cost them to plant, build or buy again. The two numbers do not match. The dispute starts there, and it rarely ends at the cashier’s window.

I saw this pattern more than any other while mediating a backlog of over 2,000 community claims against a mining operation in Mozambique. A large share of the claims were valuation disputes in disguise. People did not dispute that they had been paid. They disputed how a tree, a field or a wall had been turned into a number. Once the method was on the table and could be examined, most of those claims became solvable. While the method stayed hidden, none of them did.

This article sets out what replacement cost means, where projects quietly fall below it, and how to run a valuation process that survives contact with the people being valued.

What replacement cost means, and what it does not

IFC Performance Standard 5 is short and exact on this point. Compensation for lost assets must be at full replacement cost. The footnote defines the term: the market value of the assets plus transaction costs, with no deduction for depreciation. Market value is the value needed to replace the lost asset with one of similar value. The standard also requires that the valuation method be documented and included in the resettlement or livelihood restoration plan.

Each element of that definition closes a door projects like to leave open. Market value, not the rate in a decades-old statutory schedule. Plus transaction costs, so registration fees, transfer taxes, transport and the cost of finding the replacement are on the company, not the household. No depreciation, so an old house is valued at what it costs to build a house today, not at what a surveyor thinks the old one is worth. And a documented method, so the affected household can see how its number was produced and challenge it on the same terms.

Paragraph 9 adds the procedural half. Compensation standards must be transparent and applied consistently across everyone affected. Where livelihoods are land-based, land is offered before cash. And possession of the land is taken only after compensation has been made available. That last rule is broken more often than any other, and every breach converts a valuation question into a question of good faith.

Why statutory rates lose the argument

Many jurisdictions publish compensation schedules: a rate per crop, per tree, per square metre of a given wall type. Companies use them because they are lawful, defensible before a regulator and quick. They are also, in much of the world, wrong by the standard the lenders apply, and communities know it before the company does.

Research on farms compulsorily acquired for mining in Ghana found no express standard for crop compensation. Valuation methods and even the assumed number of plants per hectare varied from case to case, and exchange-rate movements distorted the results further. In Nigeria, the professional body of estate surveyors and valuers has said plainly that the rates prescribed by government land officers are obsolete. The depreciated replacement approach under the Land Use Act leaves people unable to replace what they lost. These are not activist positions. They are the views of the valuers who apply the schedules.

The lender standard already anticipates this. Where national rates fall below replacement cost, the project must top them up. A company that pays the statutory rate and points to the law has met the law and failed the standard, and its lender’s monitoring consultant will say so. More importantly, the household has already run its own valuation in the only market that matters to it. That market is the cost of a replacement plot, a replacement house or a replacement season. If the company’s number is lower, the company is asking people to subsidise the project. They will refuse, and the refusal will look like obstruction on the company’s risk register.

Crops and trees carry time, not just a price

A mature cashew or mango tree is not worth the price of a seedling. It is worth the seedling, plus the cost of establishing and tending it, plus the income the household loses in every year until the replacement bears at the same level. That is the output-value method the World Bank’s guidance describes for cases where no functioning market exists, and it is the only method a farmer will accept as fair. A schedule that prices a bearing tree at a flat rate, or that ignores the years to maturity, is asking the household to absorb a decade of lost harvests.

Three details decide whether a crop valuation holds. First, the count. Who walked the field, when, and with whom? A count done by a surveyor alone, in a season when the annual crop was not standing, will be contested the moment the household sees the figure. Second, the standard crop population. Where a schedule assumes a fixed number of plants per hectare, an intensively planted plot is under-counted by design. Third, timing. A harvest that would have been sold next month has a different value from one sold last month. An acquisition timed to fall between planting and harvest destroys a season the schedule never sees.

The practical answer is a joint count. The household, a community witness and the valuer walk the plot together, agree what stands on it, and sign the same sheet. It costs a morning. It removes the single most common ground of dispute I have seen, which is not the rate but the count.

Structures and the depreciation trap

Depreciation is the quiet way to under-compensate a house. A surveyor assesses a thirty-year-old dwelling, applies a depreciation factor for age and wear, and produces a figure that would not buy the materials to rebuild it. The standard forbids this. The World Bank’s guidance spells out the alternative. Value the undepreciated cost of materials and labour to build a structure of equal or better standard, plus transaction costs, with no deduction for salvage.

The same logic runs through the resettlement site. Paragraph 20 requires that new sites offer improved living conditions, not equivalent ones. Consider a household moved from a large mud-brick compound with space for goats and a kitchen garden into a smaller concrete house on a smaller plot. It has been given a better roof and a worse livelihood. The valuation of the house is only part of the transaction. What the household lost is the compound as a working unit, and that is what has to be replaced.

Ownership documentation matters here too. The standard’s footnote asks for compensation arrangements to be issued in the names of both spouses. Where the cheque goes to one name and the household economy depended on two people’s assets, the compensation can leave the household within a year without ever leaving the family.

The process failures behind the numbers

Valuation disputes that reach a mediator usually have a process failure underneath the arithmetic. The method was never disclosed, so the figure looks arbitrary. There was no independent valuer, so the company set the price for what it was buying. The household signed under pressure, with the bulldozer visible from the doorway, and later says so. Payment arrived months after possession, in a currency that had lost value, with no interest and no adjustment. Cash was paid where land was owed, and the cash is gone.

Each of these has a straightforward preventive. Publish the valuation method in the plan, in the local language, before the first survey. Use a valuer the community had a voice in choosing, or at least a valuer whose work a community-nominated expert can check. Give households the option of in-kind replacement, which paragraph 21 says should be considered in place of cash. Pay before taking possession, every time, and index late payments. Record every asset, count and signature so that a dispute two years later can be checked against a file rather than against two memories. The advice I give communities in Leveling the Table: Independent Advice for Communities applies in mirror image to companies. The side that controls the valuation carries the burden of making it checkable.

Why valuation disputes belong in a mediated process

A valuation dispute cannot be closed by paying a little more. If the household believes the method was unfair, a higher figure produced by the same method is still unfair, and the family next door will file the same claim tomorrow. What resolves the dispute is agreement on method, and method is exactly what a structured, independently facilitated process can put on the table.

In practice this means joint fact-finding rather than competing valuations. The parties agree a valuer or a panel, agree what will be counted and how, re-value a sample of contested cases together, and apply the agreed method across the rest. Where the original count cannot be reconstructed, the process agrees a fair proxy rather than defaulting to the company’s file. The land access and resettlement disputes that escalate into blockades and litigation almost always passed through a stage where this conversation could have been had cheaply. And where the loss was never recognised as displacement at all, the valuation argument sits on top of a deeper problem. I describe that problem in Physical and Economic Displacement: Why the Distinction Decides the Outcome.

Check your valuation before the community does

Run every land-acquisition valuation against the Compensation Valuation Fairness Checklist before figures are offered. It is a 15-point checklist in five sections: the valuation standard applied, crop and tree valuation, structures and resettlement housing, process safeguards, and payment and documentation. Score each item In place, Partial or Absent. A Partial on “method disclosed before survey” or an Absent on “payment before possession” predicts the disputes you will be mediating next year. Both are cheaper to fix now than then. Use it with the valuer and the community liaison team together, so that the method is theirs as well as yours. Download the Compensation Valuation Fairness Checklist

Agree the method before you argue the number

Valuation is where a resettlement earns or loses its legitimacy. A fair method, disclosed and applied consistently, protects the household’s livelihood and the company’s schedule at the same time. An unfair or hidden method costs both. The family loses the means to replace what it had, and the project inherits a claims backlog that follows it through construction, operations and closure.

The Social Accord Architecture treats valuation rules as something to agree in the Blueprinting phase, before the first plot is surveyed. They are not something to defend after the first cheque is refused. Method, valuer, count procedure, in-kind options and payment sequencing are written into the agreement, with a mediated track for the cases the rules do not fit. That is dual accountability in practice. The company commits to a method it can be held to. The community commits to using the agreed track rather than the road when a figure looks wrong. Where the dispute has already formed, a mediator can still bring the parties back to method, and in my experience that is where most valuation claims are actually settled.

Before your next land take, do one thing. Take the compensation schedule to three affected households and ask them to rebuild one of their assets on paper at today’s prices. If their number and yours are far apart, you have found the dispute before it found you. To design a valuation process or mediate a compensation dispute, write to me at thomas@thomasgaultier.com.

I am Thomas Gaultier. I mediate company-community disputes in mining, oil and gas, and energy projects, and I have resolved more than 2,000 claims across Sub-Saharan Africa and Europe. More about the work, or tell me what you are dealing with.

If the relationship around a project is under pressure, or heading there, let us talk.

A 30-minute call is enough for me to understand the situation and tell you honestly whether I can help. Active opposition, a social license problem, an FPIC process that needs an independent facilitator, a negotiation a community has to prepare for, or a conflict that is not public yet but will be. It makes no difference which side of the table you are on. No obligation, no generalist pitch.

Every first conversation is confidential.

Cover of Legacy Grievances and Historical Claims by Thomas Gaultier

New release, and the last one

Legacy Grievances and Historical Claims

The tenth and final volume completes the library. It is the field guide to harm that outlived the operation: transitional justice adapted to corporate disputes, successor liability when the asset changes hands, and the pathway behind more than two thousand resolved claims.