A village below a tailings dam lives with a fear that never leaves. It does not matter that the embankment has stood for twenty years, or that the engineer of record signs the annual review. It does not matter that the company’s monitoring shows every instrument within range. The people who farm the valley floor know what a tailings facility is, because since 25 January 2019 everyone does. On that day the dam at Brumadinho in Brazil failed and killed around 270 people, most of them in the minutes after the wall gave way. The Global Industry Standard on Tailings Management followed in August 2020. It was written because the industry accepted that the old way of managing these structures, and the old way of talking to the people below them, had failed.
The engineering side of that standard is well covered. The community side is not, and it is the side that decides whether a village downstream lives with a manageable fear or an unmanageable one. This article is about the relationship between a tailings facility and the communities in its shadow. What they are entitled to know, what emergency preparedness means when it includes them, and why a siren test is not a conversation.
What the standard says about the people downstream
The GISTM is organised in six topics, fifteen principles and 77 auditable requirements, and the first topic is not engineering. It is affected communities. The standard opens by requiring operators to respect the rights of project-affected people and to engage them meaningfully throughout the life of the facility. It closes, in its sixth topic, with public disclosure and access to information, and Principle 15 requires the operator to publicly disclose and provide access to information about the facility. In between, the topic on emergency response requires operators to prepare for failure with affected communities involved. It requires them to give local authorities and emergency services enough information from breach analysis to plan for a disaster.
Read together, those provisions describe a relationship that most tailings facilities have never had with their neighbours. The village is entitled to know what is stored above it, how the facility is classified and what would happen if it failed. It is entitled to know how far and how fast the flow would travel, and what to do when the siren sounds. It is entitled to be part of designing the response, not only to be told about it. And it is entitled to information it can use, in a form it can read, rather than an engineering report posted on a corporate website.
ICMM members have committed to implement the standard as a condition of membership, with third-party validation, and investors through the Principles for Responsible Investment have committed to expect it. Companies outside those commitments are still measured against it by the communities below their dams, because the standard has become the public definition of what responsible tailings management looks like.
The right to know, and the reluctance to tell
The provision that companies find hardest is disclosure of the consequence classification and the breach analysis. The classification says how bad a failure would be, measured in lives and in damage. The breach analysis shows where the tailings would go. Companies resist sharing both, for reasons they consider responsible: fear of panic, fear of litigation, fear that the information will be misused by opponents. Consider a village that has lived below an embankment for two decades and has never seen the map that shows its houses inside the inundation zone. When the map finally appears, at a public meeting or through a leak, the village learns two things at once. It is at risk, and the company knew and did not say.
The second lesson does the lasting damage. A community can live with risk it understands and has helped prepare for. It cannot trust a company that decided on its behalf what it was allowed to know. Disclosure done early and directly, with the classification explained, the breach map walked on the ground, and the preparedness plan built together, converts a hidden risk into a shared responsibility. Disclosure forced by an incident or an activist converts it into a betrayal. The choice is the company’s, and the standard has already made it.
Disclosure also has to be repeated. A map shown once, at a meeting five years ago, to leaders who have since been replaced, has not been disclosed to the village that lives there now. People move in, children grow up, memories fade. The right to know is a standing obligation, and the annual drill is the natural moment to renew it.
Emergency preparedness that includes the people it is for
An emergency plan written by the site’s safety department and tested with the site’s workforce has prepared the site. The village below the dam is prepared only if it has been part of the plan. That means the community knows the warning signals and what each means. It has walked the evacuation routes to the assembly points in daylight and in the dark. It knows who among its own people is responsible for the elderly, the disabled and the children at school. And it has drilled the evacuation with the company and the local authority at least annually. It means the local authority and emergency services have the breach analysis, the maps and the contact chain. They have rehearsed with the company rather than merely received a copy of the plan.
It also means the plan addresses what happens after. The GISTM’s emergency topic includes long-term recovery. A community that has been evacuated needs to know where it will live, how it will be fed, and how it will be compensated if the worst happens. A plan that ends at the assembly point is half a plan. Building it together is where the fear becomes manageable, because the villagers move from being the objects of a company procedure to being its co-authors. A practitioner who came through one of my trainings described the change in a valley where the first joint drill was run. Attendance at every other company meeting rose afterwards. People had seen the company take their lives seriously, and they returned the compliment. I set out the wider principles for handling a community in acute danger in De-escalation in an Acute Crisis. The company’s conduct once trust has gone is the subject of Crisis Communications When Trust Has Collapsed.
Monitoring the dam with the neighbours
Tailings facilities are monitored intensively: piezometers, inclinometers, survey prisms, satellite interferometry, drone surveys, and the engineer of record’s inspections. Almost none of that data reaches the village. The village therefore relies on its own instruments: seepage it can see, cracks it can walk to, the colour of the stream below the toe, the sound of the pumps. Sometimes the company’s instruments say the dam is fine and the village’s eyes say something has changed. The standard’s provisions on disclosure and engagement are the bridge, and participatory monitoring is how the bridge is built.
A joint monitoring arrangement for a tailings facility does not require the community to read a piezometer. It requires an agreed set of indicators the community can observe and report, and a channel for those reports that is answered within a day. It requires regular sharing of the company’s key monitoring results in plain form, and an annual walk of the facility with community representatives and the engineer of record. It also requires that a community report of something wrong triggers an inspection, every time, whatever the instruments say. The approach I describe in Participatory Environmental Monitoring That Communities Trust applies to a dam as to a river. The community’s role has to be a decision-making one, or it is theatre.
The grievance nobody files
Fear of a dam rarely appears in a grievance register, because there is no single incident to complain about and because people assume nothing can be done. It appears instead as a background condition that colours every other dispute. The land negotiation that stalls. The meeting that turns angry over an unrelated matter. The young people who leave. A company that wants to know whether its neighbours are afraid has to ask, in perception surveys, in women’s meetings, in conversations at the toe of the dam. And having asked, it has to answer with information and involvement rather than reassurance.
Where a facility is being raised, closed or reclassified, the fear intensifies and the engagement has to intensify with it. A community that learns of a dam raise from the sight of trucks has been told, in effect, that its consent is not required. Under the GISTM’s first topic, meaningful engagement throughout the facility’s life is the operator’s obligation, and a raise is exactly the moment it is tested.
Check the community side of your tailings management
The Downstream Community Readiness Checklist has 15 points in five sections. They cover disclosure and the right to know, emergency preparedness built with the community, joint monitoring and reporting, engagement on changes to the facility, and the local authority interface. Score each item In place, Partial or Absent with the tailings engineer, the community relations lead and representatives of the settlements in the inundation zone together. Absents in the first section mean the village does not know what sits above it. Absents in the second mean the emergency plan has prepared the site and not the people. Use it annually and after any change in the facility’s classification or design. Download the Downstream Community Readiness Checklist
A dam is a relationship as well as a structure
The people below a tailings facility are the ones who bear its ultimate risk. Their trust in the structure is inseparable from their trust in the company that operates it. A company that discloses, prepares and monitors with them has made the risk shared and the fear manageable. One that manages the embankment and not the relationship has left the largest social risk on the site unaddressed. It will surface at the moment the company most needs the valley’s cooperation. Livelihoods and investment sit in the same inundation zone.
The Social Accord Architecture treats a tailings facility as a standing item in the accord. Disclosure, preparedness, joint monitoring and the engagement required for any change are written in as commitments with owners and dates. The council reviews them and the Feedback Loop carries the community’s observations to the engineers. The mediation pathway handles the disputes that a dam generates: contested breach maps, evacuation routes across someone’s land, compensation for the fear itself. Dual accountability holds the company to telling the truth about the structure and the community to raising its concerns through the arrangement rather than through the media. Where the relationship has already broken, over a raise, a leak or a map nobody had seen, an independent mediator can still convene the parties. The company, the engineers, the authority and the village. They gather around the one document that matters, which is the plan for the worst day.
One thing to do this quarter. Take the breach analysis map for your largest facility to the settlement nearest the toe and ask its leaders whether they have seen it. If they have not, you have found the most important conversation on your site. To design the community side of tailings management or to mediate a dispute over a facility, write to me at thomas@thomasgaultier.com.