Thomas Gaultier
Menu

Resettlement Completion Audits and the Grievances They Surface

Thomas Gaultier 9 min read

The completion audit is the moment a resettlement finds out what it actually did. For years the plan has been reported through monitoring tables that the project wrote about itself. Then an external team arrives, walks the resettlement site, interviews households the monitoring never reached, and compares outcomes against the objectives the plan promised. What surfaces is rarely fraud. It is the residue. The household that was never on the list. The borehole that was built and never maintained. The transitional allowance that stopped after six months. The valuation a family accepted and never agreed with.

Companies tend to treat that residue as a legal problem, to be managed by counsel and closed with releases. That is the wrong frame, and it is expensive. Every item the audit surfaces is a grievance that has been waiting for a forum. Handle it as a claim to be defended and you convert a corrective action plan into a decade of litigation and a legacy file for whoever buys the mine. Handle it as a dispute to be resolved and the audit becomes the last chance to close the resettlement properly, before the monitoring period ends and the lender walks away.

This article is about what the audit is for, what it tends to find, and how to design the residual-claims track that makes those findings closable.

What the audit is and when it happens

IFC Performance Standard 5 is precise about the audit. Implementation of a resettlement or livelihood restoration plan is complete when the adverse impacts have been addressed in a manner consistent with the plan. They must also be consistent with the objectives of the standard itself. Depending on the scale and complexity of the displacement, the company may need to commission an external completion audit to assess whether the plan’s provisions have been met. It is done by competent resettlement professionals once the agreed monitoring period is over. It also waits until displaced people are deemed to have had adequate opportunity and assistance to restore their livelihoods sustainably.

The audit’s minimum content is set out in paragraph 15 and its footnote. A review of the totality of mitigation measures implemented. A comparison of outcomes against the agreed objectives. A conclusion on whether monitoring can end. And, where necessary, a Corrective Action Plan listing the outstanding actions needed to meet the objectives. The Guidance Note adds the timing that matters commercially. The audit should happen after all inputs in the plan are complete but well before the company’s financial commitments to the lender are met. That way corrective actions can be finished while the lender can still insist on them.

Two things follow from this design. The audit is a test of outcomes, not of activities. A plan that delivered every house and every payment can still fail if livelihoods were not restored. And the audit is supposed to produce a to-do list, not a certificate. A completion audit with no corrective actions is either a remarkable resettlement or an audit that did not look very hard.

The standard also says who the audit answers to. Paragraph 14 requires that affected people be consulted during monitoring, and the audit is the last and most important act of monitoring. An audit that interviews the resettlement manager and reads the files has audited the company’s account of itself. An audit that sits with households, walks the plots and asks the host village what changed has audited the resettlement. Insist on the second, and write it into the terms of reference.

What the audit tends to find

The findings repeat across projects with a regularity that should embarrass the industry. The first is the missing household. These are people who used the land, were absent at the census or fell into the eligibility category nobody processed. They have spent years asking to be recognised. The second is the unbuilt or unmaintained service: the school without teachers, the borehole without a pump attendant, the road that was graded once. The third is the transitional support that ended on a date rather than on a result, leaving households whose incomes never recovered. The fourth is the contested valuation, the tree count or house measurement a family signed for under pressure and has disputed at every meeting since.

The livelihood finding is the one that decides the audit. Studies of mining resettlement in Ghana and Sierra Leone document household incomes and food security below pre-displacement levels years after the move. An auditor comparing outcomes against the plan’s own objective, to improve or at least restore livelihoods, will find the gap unless the monitoring closed it. The reasons I set out in Livelihood Restoration Beyond the Cash Payment are usually behind it. Cash where land was owed. Training for jobs that did not exist. Support that stopped too early.

A less visible finding is the host community. Where the site was placed on another village’s land and that village was never treated as a party, the audit finds a second set of affected people. They have no entitlements and a live grievance. The pattern is the one I describe in Host Communities: The Resettlement Party Nobody Consults. It is rarely in the audit’s terms of reference until the auditors are on site.

When findings arrive, the instinct is to protect the company. Counsel points out that every household signed an agreement, that the statutory process was followed, that the monitoring period is closing and the claims are out of time. All of this may be true and none of it closes a grievance. A household that believes it was undercounted or underpaid does not stop believing it because a release was signed. A community that watched the audit team arrive expects something to change.

Refusing to reopen turns the audit into evidence for the other side. Corrective actions that were recommended and not taken become the core of a complaint to the lender’s accountability mechanism or a submission to a national human rights institution. Or they become a legacy claim that reappears at the next expansion, the next financing or the sale of the asset. The legal position is preserved and the project inherits a grievance with an independent report attached. In my experience the residual claims are also the ones with the strongest facts, because they have survived years of being told no. The weak claims drop away in the first year. What remains at audit time is the field that really was used, the tree count that really was wrong, the widow who really was left off the list.

Designing the residual-claims track

The alternative is to treat the audit’s findings as the input to a defined, time-bound, mediated track for residual claims. The standard already requires the frame: paragraph 11 asks for a grievance mechanism for displaced persons and host communities, with a recourse mechanism designed to resolve disputes impartially. The residual-claims track is that recourse mechanism applied to the audit.

It has five parts. First, disclosure: the audit’s findings are shared with the affected communities in a form they can understand, and households are invited to bring claims the audit did not capture. Second, a register with categories: unlisted persons, service and infrastructure gaps, livelihood shortfalls, valuation disputes, host community claims. Third, an agreed evidence standard for each category, decided with community representatives, so that a claim about an unlisted field is tested against use rather than against title. Fourth, an independent facilitator or mediator for the claims that the register cannot settle on paper. The company and the claimant agree an outcome the auditor can verify. Fifth, a closing rule: the track runs until the corrective action plan is complete and the claimant confirms the outcome, not until a date on the lender’s calendar.

The Mozambique mandate I was brought into as an independent mediator was, in effect, a residual-claims track built years after the fact. It cost far more than one designed at audit time would have. A backlog of more than 2,000 claims, most of them about land, valuation and recognition, took two years and a community-approved global settlement to close. Almost every one of those claims could have been surfaced and settled by a track designed when the resettlement was still open. The lesson I draw from it is not that backlogs can be cleared. It is that they should never have to be.

Preparing for the audit before it arrives

The best time to design the residual-claims track is before the audit, because a project that has been monitoring properly already knows most of what the audit will find. Household-level tracking against the baseline, with affected people consulted during monitoring as paragraph 14 requires, shows which households have not recovered. A grievance register read by category shows which valuations and which services are still contested. A quiet check of the census against the people actually living around the site shows who was missed.

A project that runs that self-assessment a year before the audit can fix much of it in time and can hand the auditors a corrective action plan already under way. That changes the audit from an exposure into a confirmation. It also changes the conversation with the community, who see the company looking for its own gaps instead of waiting to be caught.

Know what the audit will find before the auditors do

The Resettlement Completion Readiness Checklist walks a project through that self-assessment. It has 16 points in five sections. They cover outcomes against the plan’s objectives, coverage of everyone affected including hosts, services in working order, livelihood restoration evidence at household level, and the residual-claims track itself. Score each item In place, Partial or Absent. A cluster of Absents in the livelihood section means the audit will conclude that the objective was not met, and the corrective actions will be expensive. Absents in the last section mean the findings will have nowhere to go but the lender’s complaints office. Run it twelve months before the audit and again three months before. Download the Resettlement Completion Readiness Checklist

Close the resettlement, not the file

A resettlement is finished when the people it displaced have livelihoods at least as good as before and say so, not when a report says monitoring may end. The audit exists to test the first claim against the second. Treating its findings as attacks to be repelled protects nobody. The households stay uncompensated, and the company carries an independent record of unmet commitments into every future financing and every future dispute.

The Social Accord Architecture treats the completion audit as a stewardship event, planned from the start. The agreement names the audit, its timing and its evidence standard, and it establishes the residual-claims track and its mediated tier before the first household moves. Dual accountability makes the close credible. The company is accountable for the corrective actions, the community for bringing claims through the track rather than around it. An independent hand verifies both. That is how a resettlement ends with a relationship rather than a release. Where the audit has already happened and the findings are sitting with counsel, a mediator can still convert them into a resolution track. The earlier that happens, the less it costs.

One step to take this quarter if you have a resettlement approaching its monitoring end. Ask your team for the list of households whose income is still below baseline and the list of grievances still open. Put both in front of the community before the auditors do. To design a residual-claims track or to mediate the findings of a completion audit, write to me at thomas@thomasgaultier.com.

I am Thomas Gaultier. I mediate company-community disputes in mining, oil and gas, and energy projects, and I have resolved more than 2,000 claims across Sub-Saharan Africa and Europe. More about the work, or tell me what you are dealing with.

If the relationship around a project is under pressure, or heading there, let us talk.

A 30-minute call is enough for me to understand the situation and tell you honestly whether I can help. Active opposition, a social license problem, an FPIC process that needs an independent facilitator, a negotiation a community has to prepare for, or a conflict that is not public yet but will be. It makes no difference which side of the table you are on. No obligation, no generalist pitch.

Every first conversation is confidential.

Cover of Legacy Grievances and Historical Claims by Thomas Gaultier

New release, and the last one

Legacy Grievances and Historical Claims

The tenth and final volume completes the library. It is the field guide to harm that outlived the operation: transitional justice adapted to corporate disputes, successor liability when the asset changes hands, and the pathway behind more than two thousand resolved claims.