Thomas Gaultier
Menu

Local Procurement: Turning Supplier Promises into Working Contracts

Thomas Gaultier 8 min read

Procurement is where most of a mine’s money actually lands in a country, and almost none of it lands in the village. The agreement promised local business opportunities. The company’s procurement team, sitting in the capital or abroad, buys from suppliers it knows, on terms designed for firms with credit lines and accountants. The village bakery that was told it could supply the camp discovers a tender document in English and a requirement for insurance it cannot get. It finds ninety-day payment terms it cannot survive, and a volume it could not deliver anyway. The bakery does not get the contract. The company reports that no qualified local suppliers exist. Both statements are true, and the promise is broken. The bakery tells the village. The village adds it to the list.

Local procurement fails for structural reasons that are well understood and rarely addressed. Mining Shared Value’s work on local procurement reporting began from a simple observation. Procurement is usually the largest in-country payment a site makes, and there was no common way even to measure how much of it stayed local. The IGF’s guidance for governments treats procurement, employment and skills as the three levers of local content. Procurement is the one with the most money and the least practice behind it. This article is about turning a supplier promise into contracts that a village enterprise can win, deliver and survive.

Define local before you count it

As with employment, the first dispute is the definition. A supplier registered in the capital with a post-office box in the district is local by most companies’ reporting and by nobody else’s. A firm owned by a national politician and staffed from the city is local by nationality and not by any measure the village recognises. The LPRM’s 22 disclosures exist partly to force this question: what does the site mean by local, and how much of its spend goes to each category? Without a tiered definition, the company’s local procurement figure and the community’s experience of it will never match, and the community will conclude the figure is a lie.

A workable definition is tiered like employment: enterprises owned and operated within the footprint settlements, then the district, then the province, then the country. Ownership and location both matter, and so does where the workforce comes from. Publish the tiers and report against each. A site that reports honestly that most of its spend is national and a small share is district-level, with a plan to grow the district share, is believed. A site that reports a large local figure that the village cannot see is not.

Unbundle, or nobody local can bid

The second structural barrier is contract size. A camp catering contract for two thousand meals a day, bundled with laundry, cleaning and waste, can only be won by a national or international firm. The same contract unbundled, with fresh produce, bread, eggs and laundry as separate lots, can be supplied by a dozen village enterprises and a district cooperative. Unbundling costs the procurement team time and management effort, which is why it is not done, and it is the single most effective local procurement measure available. The catering contractor can also be required to source defined categories locally, with the requirement flowed down and reported.

Match the lots to what exists. A supplier survey of the footprint settlements and the district, done before construction, answers three questions. What can be bought locally today, what could be bought with modest support, and what cannot. The categories that recur are food, transport, labour hire, construction materials such as sand, gravel and blocks, uniforms and protective equipment, camp services, fencing, landscaping and rehabilitation work. None of these is technically demanding. All of them are usually bought from outside because nobody looked inside first. A practitioner who came through one of my trainings described a site that imported eggs by road for two years while three villages within sight of the camp kept chickens. Nobody in procurement had asked, and nobody in community relations had been asked.

Terms a small enterprise can survive

A village enterprise can win a contract and be destroyed by its terms. Ninety-day payment kills a supplier that has to pay its workers weekly. A requirement for insurance, tax clearance and audited accounts before the first order excludes everyone who has never had a formal contract. A tender in the company’s language, submitted through a portal, with a two-week window, is not a tender the village can enter. None of these terms is malicious. They are the default terms of a procurement system designed for a different supplier, and changing them requires a decision.

The changes are practical. Payment within fourteen days for small local suppliers, or an advance against the first delivery. Registration requirements phased in, with support to meet them, rather than imposed as a gate. Tenders in local languages, with a supplier day in the district where the requirements are explained and questions answered. Purchase orders sized to what the enterprise can deliver, with volume growing as performance is proven. A single point of contact in the procurement team for local suppliers, because a bakery cannot work its way through a corporate helpdesk. And a supplier development programme, run with a partner who knows small business, covering bookkeeping, quality, safety and the paperwork the company needs. The ICMM Community Development Toolkit has treated local business development as a community development tool for years. The reason is that supplier development and community development are the same activity looked at from two ends.

Capture: the dispute that follows success

Where local procurement starts working, a new dispute arrives. The contracts go to the connected. The chief’s brother forms a transport company the week the tender is announced. A district official’s family wins the sand supply. The village that was promised opportunities watches a handful of families grow rich on them, and the grievance is now against the company for having chosen them. I have heard this story relayed in my trainings from more countries than I can count. It is the most predictable consequence of a procurement programme that has no rules about who benefits.

The defences are the same as for hiring: transparency and distribution. Publish every local contract awarded, to whom, for what, for how much. Cap the number or value of contracts any single enterprise or family can hold in the first years. Use cooperatives and community enterprises for categories such as produce and labour hire, so that the benefit spreads. Involve a community committee in verifying that a supplier is what it claims to be, without letting the committee allocate contracts. And report to the community, not only to head office, on where the money went. The community will find out anyway. The only question is whether it finds out from the company or from the size of one family’s new house.

Capture also has a company-side version. The procurement officer who steers local contracts to a relative, or who takes a share, is a corruption risk the community will attribute to the company as a whole. Publication protects the company from its own staff as much as from the chief’s brother.

Measuring what stays

What is measured is what gets managed, and local procurement has been unmeasured for most of the industry’s history. The LPRM’s disclosures give a site a structure. Total procurement spend, spend by locality tier, number of local suppliers, categories procured locally, the policies and systems in place, and the supplier development effort. A site that reports on these annually, and shares the report with the community and local government, converts a vague promise into a tracked commitment. It also gives the procurement team a reason to care, because a number that appears in a public report gets attention that a number in a spreadsheet does not. The social performance indicators that measure relationship quality belong beside the procurement figures, because the two move together.

Local procurement is also one of the few community benefits that lasts. Jobs end at demobilisation. A supplier that has learned to meet a mining company’s standards can sell to the next mine, the road contractor and the regional market. The point I make in Community Development That Lasts applies with particular force here: an enterprise is an asset the community keeps.

Test whether your supplier promise can be kept

The Local Procurement Readiness Checklist has 15 points in five sections. They cover the definition of local and the supplier survey, unbundling and category matching, terms a small enterprise can survive, defences against capture, and measurement and reporting. Score each item In place, Partial or Absent with the procurement team and the community relations team together, because the gap between the two is where the promise usually fails. Absents in the third section mean local firms can win contracts and not survive them. Absents in the fourth mean the programme’s first success will be its first scandal. Review it before the main construction contracts are let, since that is when the categories are fixed. Download the Local Procurement Readiness Checklist

Contracts are commitments, and commitments need a forum

A local procurement programme that works changes the relationship between a project and its neighbours more than any community fund. It moves the community from recipient to counterparty, and it leaves assets behind that no closure plan takes away. One that fails, or that enriches a few, produces a grievance with the company’s own procurement figures as evidence against it. The community’s livelihoods and the project’s standing are tied together in either case.

The way to make it work is to treat the procurement arrangement as a negotiated commitment, tracked and reviewed with the community, rather than as a procurement policy. The Social Accord Architecture writes the procurement arrangement into the accord as commitments with owners and dates. That means the definition of local, the unbundled categories, the payment terms, the anti-capture rules and the annual reporting. The commitments register tracks the spend by tier and the council reviews it. The disputes, a contract that went to the wrong family, a supplier that was never paid, go to the mediation pathway rather than to the gate. Dual accountability holds the company to the terms it agreed and the community’s institutions to policing capture on their own side. Where a procurement dispute has already hardened, an independent mediator can put the procurement figures, the community’s list of who got what, and the agreement on the same table. That is usually enough to start.

One thing to do this quarter. Ask your procurement team for last year’s spend within twenty kilometres of the gate, by supplier. If they cannot produce the list in a day, you do not have a local procurement programme. You have a promise, and the village has been keeping its own list of who got what since the first truck arrived. To design a local procurement arrangement or to mediate a dispute over one, write to me at thomas@thomasgaultier.com.

I am Thomas Gaultier. I mediate company-community disputes in mining, oil and gas, and energy projects, and I have resolved more than 2,000 claims across Sub-Saharan Africa and Europe. More about the work, or tell me what you are dealing with.

If the relationship around a project is under pressure, or heading there, let us talk.

A 30-minute call is enough for me to understand the situation and tell you honestly whether I can help. Active opposition, a social license problem, an FPIC process that needs an independent facilitator, a negotiation a community has to prepare for, or a conflict that is not public yet but will be. It makes no difference which side of the table you are on. No obligation, no generalist pitch.

Every first conversation is confidential.

Cover of Legacy Grievances and Historical Claims by Thomas Gaultier

New release, and the last one

Legacy Grievances and Historical Claims

The tenth and final volume completes the library. It is the field guide to harm that outlived the operation: transitional justice adapted to corporate disputes, successor liability when the asset changes hands, and the pathway behind more than two thousand resolved claims.