A grievance mechanism is judged by its clock. A complainant does not experience the policy, the governance model or the lender’s approval letter. They experience how long it takes to hear back, whether the date they were given is kept, and what happens when the company’s first answer is no. Predictability is one of the eight effectiveness criteria in the UN Guiding Principles for exactly this reason. It means a clear procedure with an indicative time frame for each stage, and clarity about what outcomes are possible. Most mechanisms have the procedure. Fewer keep the clock.
The other thing a complainant experiences is the ceiling. In a mechanism with one tier, the company’s answer is the final answer, and the only route past it is the road or the court. In a mechanism with an escalation ladder, a refused remedy goes somewhere: to a senior review, to an independent mediator, to an appeal. The ladder is what turns a complaint desk into a dispute resolution system. When I was brought in as an independent mediator to a backlog of more than 2,000 claims in Mozambique, the backlog existed because the ladder did not. Once a mediated tier was in place, the cases moved. Not quickly, and not all at once. But a claim that had sat for years, because the company’s first answer was also its last, now had a table to go to. Both sides had a reason to sit at it.
This article sets out the timelines, the severity tiers and the escalation ladder that make a mechanism predictable in practice.
Six steps and a clock on each
The process I use has six steps, and each carries a time standard. Receive and document: the grievance is logged the day it arrives, in the complainant’s words, with a case number. Assess and assign: within a few days the case is classified by severity and given an owner. Acknowledge and inform: within five business days of receipt the complainant hears back. They get the case number, a summary they can correct, the next steps and the name of the person holding the case. They also get the assurances that matter: no retaliation, and the right to go elsewhere at any stage. Investigate and dialogue: the facts are established, with the complainant present for site visits where possible. Respond and negotiate remedy: a proposal is made and discussed, not announced. Follow-up and close-out: the remedy is verified as delivered and the complainant confirms, or the case moves up the ladder.
The five-day acknowledgment is the standard I defend hardest, because its absence does the fastest damage. On a programme I supported in southern Africa, acknowledgments slipped by a week during an intake surge. By the end of that week the story in the community was not that the office was behind. It was that the company reads the forms and throws them away. Two households with live grievances did not file that month. The standard was restored within days. The story took a season of kept promises to bury.
The lesson is not that five days is a magic number. It is that the first response sets the community’s theory of the mechanism. A fast, specific acknowledgment says the form went somewhere and someone owns it. Silence says the opposite, and silence is what people talk about at the water point.
Severity tiers decide the timeline
Not every grievance deserves the same clock. Pretending otherwise produces either a mechanism that treats a cracked wall like a death, or one that treats a death like a cracked wall. Three severity levels are enough. Level 1 covers routine, low-impact concerns with a straightforward fix: a noise complaint, a delayed payment, a blocked path. Level 2 covers grievances with material impact on a household or group: crop damage, water access, a valuation dispute. Level 3 covers anything involving injury, displacement, cultural heritage, security providers, gender-based harm, or a community-wide claim.
Each level carries its own target for investigation and response, and the higher the level the more the process changes shape. Level 3 cases get senior ownership from day one, an investigator independent of the department involved, and board-level visibility. Anything alleging that a security provider retaliated against a complainant is Level 3 automatically. Letting security investigate security is a conflict of interest visible to everyone, and most of all to the complainant. The tiering also protects against a quiet bias I have seen in more than one register. Land and employment claims filed by men are rated as serious, water and garden claims filed by women as minor, and the averages look fine. Severity criteria should rate livelihood impacts, including subsistence and water access, at Level 2 or above, and someone should check the register for that pattern each quarter.
Extensions: the rule that saves the relationship
Timelines are targets, not promises the sky will fall if missed. Some Level 3 cases take longer than any standard, because they need laboratory results, a joint site visit that depends on the season, or an external mediator’s diary. Predictability does not require that every case close on time. It requires that the complainant knows what to expect and is told when the expectation changes.
Three rules make extensions safe. Notify before the original date passes, with the reason and a new date, never after. Document the reason, and accept only real ones: awaiting a lab, scheduling a joint visit, coordinating a mediator. Staff leave and workload are not reasons a complainant should absorb. And limit extensions. One of up to fifteen business days is normal for a Level 2 or 3 case, and a second escalates the case to site leadership. A case open beyond sixty business days without documented progress is a systemic failure, not a complex case. A deadline that passes silently converts a manageable grievance into evidence that the mechanism is a performance. A deadline moved openly, with a reason the complainant can check, does the reverse. It shows the process is real enough to run late honestly.
The escalation ladder
The ladder is what happens when the company’s proposed remedy is refused. Without one, refusal ends the process and the complainant is told, politely, that the file is closed. With one, refusal starts the next stage. The first rung is a senior review within the company, by someone who did not handle the case. The second is mediation by an independent third party. The third is an appeal or external review: a community panel, an ombudsman, a lender’s accountability mechanism or the courts. The complainant keeps the right to use any of these at any point, regardless of the ladder.
Mediation is the rung that does the work, and it should be triggered in defined circumstances rather than left to goodwill. Impasse on remedy: a proposal has been made and refused, and further exchange produces repetition rather than movement. Power imbalance: the complainant is negotiating without information, advice or technical support. A mediator can level the field with equal time, caucus, and the right to take any proposal to an advisor. Multi-party or community-wide grievances that need structuring and sequencing. Cases where the relationship has to survive for decades. And sensitive cases, cultural heritage, livelihood displacement, reputational exposure, where a formal process would do harm.
Mediation is also not for everything. Criminal conduct goes to law enforcement. An immediate safety risk is dealt with before any process. A grievance involving gender-based violence is never mediated between survivor and alleged perpetrator and follows its own pathway. And a party unwilling to engage in good faith cannot be mediated with. Participation is voluntary, and a complainant who declines keeps every other route. The craft of that tier is what I set out in When to Call a Mediator, and When to Trust Your Own Team.
Close-out is a verification, not a status
Close-out is the step most often skipped, and skipping it is how a mechanism produces broken promises that its own dashboard records as successes. I have seen registers in which cases were marked closed on the day the agreement was signed, with no evidence that the remedy was ever delivered. A case qualifies for closure when the agreed remedy has been implemented and the complainant has confirmed satisfaction. It also qualifies when the appeal options are exhausted and the final response is documented. That means a site inspection for a physical remedy, a confirmed receipt for a payment, and evidence that a procedural change was made and communicated. For phased remedies, livelihood restoration or environmental rehabilitation, define interim milestones and verify each before final closure.
Target close-out within ten business days of remedy delivery, and never on the day of signature for a remedy that takes months. Then feed the closed case forward, flagging recurring issues for root-cause work. A close-out done this way produces the only advertising a mechanism needs, which is a complainant who tells the neighbours that the process is slow but fair. The design foundations for all of this are in Designing Grievance Mechanisms That Actually Resolve Conflict; this article is about keeping them running.
Test the clock and the ladder on your own register
The Grievance Process Timeline and Escalation Checklist is a 16-point checklist in five sections. They cover intake and acknowledgment standards, severity tiering, extension discipline, the escalation ladder including mediation triggers, and close-out verification. Score each item In place, Partial or Absent against your register, not your procedure. The distinction matters: most mechanisms score well on the procedure and badly on the register, and the register is what the community experiences. A cluster of Absents in the ladder section means refused remedies have nowhere to go, which is the condition that produces backlogs and blockades. Use it quarterly alongside the effectiveness audit. Download the Grievance Process Timeline and Escalation Checklist
The ladder is the mechanism
A mechanism with a clock but no ladder is a complaints desk. It can be fast and courteous and still leave every serious dispute with no exit but the road. A mechanism with a ladder but no clock is a promise of process that arrives too late to matter. Together they are what the predictability criterion actually describes, and together they are what protects both the household with the grievance and the company with the investment. A refused remedy that goes to a mediator instead of a blockade costs days rather than weeks of production, and it settles the case in a way both sides own.
The Social Accord Architecture treats the grievance mechanism as one layer of a larger structure. Its escalation ladder is wired into the mediation pathway, GROUNDS, and its outcomes flow into a commitments register the community can see. That is where dual accountability lives: the company is held to the clock and the remedies, and the community is held to using the ladder rather than bypassing it. In Mozambique the mediated tier did not just clear a backlog. It gave both sides a reason to trust the mechanism that replaced it.
One thing to check this week. Pull the ten oldest open cases from your register and, for each, write down the date the complainant was last told anything. If any of those dates is more than a month old, your clock has stopped, whatever the procedure says. To design an escalation ladder or to set up the mediated tier of a grievance mechanism, write to me at thomas@thomasgaultier.com.