Thomas Gaultier
Menu

The Ethics of Dual Loyalty in Community Relations

Thomas Gaultier 9 min read

Whose side are you on

Ask a community relations practitioner who they work for and you will get a careful answer, because the honest one is uncomfortable. On paper, they work for the company. The company pays them, writes their objectives, and decides whether they keep their job. In the community hall, though, they are the one person expected to understand the residents, advocate for them internally, and be believed when they say a promise will be kept. The role is built to serve two parties whose interests do not always align. That is not a personal failing of the person in the chair. It is the defining ethical condition of the job, and pretending it does not exist is how practitioners get hurt and communities get betrayed.

There is a name for this condition, borrowed from a profession that has studied it for decades. It is called dual loyalty. In health-professional ethics, dual loyalty describes the conflict a clinician faces when duties to a patient collide with obligations to a third party. That third party is usually an employer, an insurer, or the state. Physicians for Human Rights built an entire framework around it, because unmanaged dual loyalty is how well-meaning professionals end up complicit in harm they never intended. The parallel to community relations is close enough to be useful. The practitioner owes something real to the company and something real to the community, and the two debts come due at the same moment. This article is about that conflict, and about the one ethical stance that resolves it without asking the practitioner to betray either side.

The two loyalties are both real

The temptation is to resolve dual loyalty by declaring one loyalty the true one. Neither move survives contact with the work.

Say the practitioner is loyal only to the company. Then community relations becomes what its critics accuse it of being. It turns into a function that manufactures the appearance of consultation, manages expectations downward, and absorbs anger so it never reaches the people who could act on it. A practitioner who serves the company alone will help obtain permissions through managed impressions rather than genuine engagement. They will translate every corporate refusal into softer language, and look away from problems rather than surface them. Communities are not fooled by this for long. They can read a person who is only there to handle them, and once they have read it, nothing that person says carries weight. The company has bought itself a liability that looks like an asset.

Now say the practitioner is loyal only to the community. This sounds more virtuous and fails almost as fast. A practitioner who treats their employer as the adversary loses the internal credibility that is their only real tool. They stop being invited to the meetings where decisions are made. They get reclassified as a problem, managed around, and eventually removed. Their advocacy dies with their access. Worse, they can raise community expectations they have no power to satisfy, which sets up the exact broken promise that does the most damage to trust. Pure loyalty to the community, without the standing to deliver anything, is a comfort to the practitioner’s conscience and a disservice to the people they meant to help.

Both single loyalties fail because the situation is genuinely dual. The community’s interest in fair treatment and the company’s interest in a viable project are not identical, but they are not permanent enemies either. A resettlement done properly serves both. A grievance resolved early serves both. A sacred site protected before it becomes a blockade serves both. The practitioner’s real job is to find and enlarge the ground where the two interests overlap, and to be honest with each side about where they do not. That requires holding both loyalties at once, which is exactly the thing that makes the role hard and the thing most operating models refuse to support.

The refusal is usually structural rather than deliberate. A practitioner sits inside the company’s reporting line, is measured on company objectives, and is rewarded for keeping the project on schedule. Nothing in that structure rewards them for surfacing a problem that slows the project down. Surfacing it is often the honest thing, and the thing that prevents a larger failure later. So the dual loyalty is real, but the incentives point one way. That imbalance is what turns an ethical tension the practitioner could manage into a trap the practitioner absorbs, and it is why the fix has to be structural too.

Where the conflict actually bites

Dual loyalty is abstract until a specific decision forces it into the open. It bites hardest at a handful of recurring moments, and naming them helps a practitioner see the conflict coming rather than discovering it too late.

Consider a scenario drawn from patterns common across extractive projects. A survey has cleared a route for a road, and the technical team wants to proceed. But the practitioner has learned through community work that the route crosses a burial ground the survey never asked about. The company loyalty says keep the project moving. The community loyalty says stop and protect the site. The conflict is real, and it will be decided one way or the other by what the practitioner chooses to do with what they know. A second recurring moment: a compensation schedule that is legally defensible but visibly unfair to a group of widows whose land was registered to dead male relatives. A third: a local hiring promise that the company is quietly preparing to satisfy with outside contractors. Each of these is a live dual-loyalty conflict, and each has the same structure. The practitioner knows something that serves the community, and surfacing it costs the company money, time, or convenience.

What a practitioner does at these moments defines their ethics more than any policy statement. The critique that community relations legitimises harm has substance precisely because some practitioners resolve these conflicts by default in the company’s favour, every time, and call it pragmatism. But the opposite caricature is also false. Practitioners do change routes, improve compensation, and put teeth into hiring commitments, and communities are materially better off when they do. The lesson from the role of acknowledgment in resolving mining conflict applies here. Honesty about a real harm, offered in time, is worth more to both sides than a defended silence. The dual-loyalty conflict is not resolved by picking a side. It is resolved by surfacing the truth to both sides and fighting for the overlap.

The honest test, and the red lines

Because dual loyalty cannot be resolved by allegiance, it has to be managed by a discipline. The discipline has two parts: an honest ongoing test, and a small set of lines that are not for negotiating.

The honest test is a question the practitioner has to answer privately and repeatedly. Not what does my job description say I am achieving, and not what do I hope I am achieving, but what is actually happening as a result of my involvement. A practitioner doing genuine good can usually point to specific outcomes: a route moved, a payment corrected, a complaint resolved that would otherwise have festered. A practitioner who has slid into pure company service cannot, because their honest answer is that they are mostly making harm more acceptable. That answer, faced squarely, is the beginning of ethical practice. Avoiding it is how good people drift into complicity without ever deciding to. This is the sharpest edge of the human cost documented in the invisible toll of social performance work, because the drift does not announce itself.

Then there are the red lines, the things a practitioner will not do regardless of what serving the company seems to require. These are personal and worth deciding in advance, in calm conditions, before a specific pressure makes them negotiable. Common ones: I will not knowingly help obtain consent that is not informed. I will not misrepresent a material fact to a community. I will not stay silent about a serious harm to protect a timeline. I will not gather signatures on an agreement I know the community understands differently from the company. A practitioner who has named their red lines has a place to stand when the pressure comes. A practitioner who has not will find the lines moving quietly under their feet, one reasonable-sounding exception at a time. Knowing your red lines also tells you when to escalate, and when escalation fails, when to refuse, and in the last resort when to leave. The willingness to walk away is what gives every other line its force.

Test whether your practitioner can serve both sides honestly

The Dual Loyalty Ethics Audit is a framework for examining whether a community relations role lets its practitioner serve both sides honestly, or quietly forces them to pick one. It sets out its checkpoints in five sections. Those are recognising the conflict, the pull toward company-only loyalty, the pull toward community-only loyalty, the honest-assessment discipline, and the red lines and escalation paths. Rather than a score, use the framework to compare your operation against each condition. It locates where the structure is loading the ethical conflict onto one person to absorb alone. Read the company-pull and community-pull sections side by side to see which way your incentives actually bend. Then use the red-lines section to check whether your practitioners have any protected place to stand. Bring it to a team discussion and it surfaces the conflicts people are managing in silence. Download the Dual Loyalty Ethics Audit.

Dual accountability is the resolution

The way out of dual loyalty is not to choose a loyalty. It is to convert the private conflict into a shared, structured accountability that both sides can see. That is the ethical core of Thomas Gaultier’s Social Accord Architecture, and the principle is named directly: Dual Accountability. The Social Accord Architecture, SAA for short, holds that the practitioner and the process answer honestly to the community’s livelihoods and to the company’s investment. They do so openly and at the same time, never serving one while pretending to serve both. Dual Accountability is what dual loyalty becomes when you stop hiding it and start structuring it. It gives the practitioner an explicit mandate to be straight with both sides, which is precisely the mandate the conflicted role denies them.

Structure is what makes that mandate more than a good intention. When commitments are recorded and tracked, the practitioner is not privately choosing whether to honour a promise; the process holds both sides to it. Sometimes a relationship fractures past the point where an in-house practitioner can be believed by either party. Then an independent mediator resolves the loyalty problem cleanly, because a neutral owes nothing to either side and can hold both to the same process. This is the strongest argument for mediation in contested community relations. It is not a sign the practitioner failed. It is the mechanism that lets the truth be spoken when no internal voice can be trusted to speak it. It also aligns with the access-to-remedy expectation the UN Guiding Principles place on companies. The frameworks that address human rights conflict through mediation in mining zones rest on the same logic: a structured, neutral process is how you serve both sides without betraying either.

The one commitment worth making this quarter is to stop treating your practitioner’s divided loyalty as their private burden and start structuring it as shared accountability. Name the conflict openly with the person who lives it. Help them define red lines and back those lines when they hold them. Record your commitments so honouring them is not a personal act of courage. Bring in independent facilitation before a fractured relationship forces someone to choose between their job and their integrity. A practitioner who is allowed to serve both sides honestly is the most valuable person on a project, because they are the only one both sides can believe. Protecting their integrity protects the community’s livelihoods and the company’s investment together, which was always the only version of the role worth defending. To build that accountability into your operation, reach me at thomas@thomasgaultier.com.

I am Thomas Gaultier. I mediate company-community disputes in mining, oil and gas, and energy projects, and I have resolved more than 2,000 claims across Sub-Saharan Africa and Europe. More about the work, or tell me what you are dealing with.

If the relationship around a project is under pressure, or heading there, let us talk.

A 30-minute call is enough for me to understand the situation and tell you honestly whether I can help. Active opposition, a social license problem, an FPIC process that needs an independent facilitator, a negotiation a community has to prepare for, or a conflict that is not public yet but will be. It makes no difference which side of the table you are on. No obligation, no generalist pitch.

Every first conversation is confidential.

Cover of Legacy Grievances and Historical Claims by Thomas Gaultier

New release, and the last one

Legacy Grievances and Historical Claims

The tenth and final volume completes the library. It is the field guide to harm that outlived the operation: transitional justice adapted to corporate disputes, successor liability when the asset changes hands, and the pathway behind more than two thousand resolved claims.